NEW CLIENTS! Get in Touch Today for a FREE Business Assessment!

Learning Center
We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.

Understanding Tax Relief for Scam Victims

Navigating the tax implications of scams can be challenging, especially with legislative changes limiting deductions for theft losses primarily to disaster-related incidents. However, if you’ve been a victim of fraud, there remains a vital tax relief opportunity available for you.

Historically, tax laws allowed you to deduct theft losses not covered by insurance. Changes have tightened these rules, curtailing deductions mainly to disaster-related events, yet exceptions exist. The tax code still provides for losses tied to profit-driven activities. If your scam losses stem from endeavors intended to generate profit, you may qualify for a deduction without a disaster declaration.

According to Internal Revenue Code Section 165(c)(2), losses linked to profit-motivated transactions might be deductible. Understanding this can offer significant financial relief when tackling the aftermath of deceitful scams.

Eligibility Requirements for Profit-Driven Casualty Losses: For a theft loss to qualify under this exception, several intentional criteria must be met:

  1. Profit Motive: The primary goal must be economic gain. The IRS demands clear evidence of a legitimate expectation of profit. Substantial documentation is often required to substantiate this intent.

  2. Type of Transaction: Eligible transactions are typically traditional investment vehicles such as stocks, real estate, or other income-generating activities. Non-commercial engagements usually don't qualify.

  3. Nature of Loss: The loss should directly relate to the profit-oriented transaction. This linkage must be evident and verifiable with financial and legal documentation.

Leveraging IRS Guidance: Applying this deduction often requires studying IRS memoranda and rulings for deductible losses definitions. A recent IRS Chief Counsel Memorandum (CCM 202511015) outlines when such losses may be allowed:

  • Investment Scams: Cases where losses may be deductible, provided the initial investment had a legitimate profit expectation. Documentation such as communication with scammers and financial transfer proof is crucial.

  • Theft Losses: The IRS scrutinizes these; losses must relate to a profit-driven transaction, not personal engagements.

Business Management Planning

Tax Consequences of IRA Scams: Falling victim to scams involving IRA or tax-deferred pensions can intensify your tax burden.

For traditional IRAs, premature withdrawals resulting from a scam become taxable income. This could elevate your tax bracket and liability, and if under 59½, a 10% early withdrawal penalty applies.

Speak To An Expert
Speak to an expert today on how we can help your business
Get Started

Roth IRAs face different impacts given contributions are after-tax. If meeting the five-year holding rule, contributions can be withdrawn tax-free, though premature earnings withdrawals may face penalties.

These cases demonstrate when a scam loss qualifies as a casualty loss and associated tax consequences:

Family Protection

Example 1: Impersonator Scam - Deductible Loss

Taxpayer 1 fell for a scam with a fraud impersonator leading them to move funds into supposed secure accounts. The taxpayer's goal to safeguard and reinvest confirms a profit-driven intent, making the losses deductible.

Tax Implications:

  • If itemizing deductions, losses are deductible on Schedule A.

  • Traditional IRA distributions are taxed, potentially with early withdrawal penalties, unless funds are rerolled within 60 days.

Example 2: Romance Scam - Non-Deductible Loss

Taxpayer 2, caught in a romance scam, sent funds to assist another, absent a profit motive. Losses qualify as non-deductible personal casualty losses under Section 165(c)(3).

Example 3: Kidnapping Scam - Non-Deductible Loss

Taxpayer 3, misled by a kidnapping scammer using voice-cloning technology, transferred funds not intended for profit. Stress and coercion, while influencing decisions, do not satisfy profit motive requirements, thus remaining non-deductible.

Conclusion: Understand your transaction motives and meticulously document your intentions. Engage in critical evaluation of scams to determine tax deductible potential.

  • Intent Documentation: Ensure supporting documentation prominently shows investment intentions for profit-related claims.

  • IRS Compliance: With intense scrutiny of non-disaster losses, precise adherence to IRS instructions is mandatory.

Consult with our firm before engaging in financial transactions arising from unsolicited communications. We offer strategic guidance in fraud detection and prevention. Education, particularly for vulnerable family members, safeguards against scams and protects assets aligned with the values of simplicity and honesty that underpin our services.

Traveling with Security

Speak To An Expert
Speak to an expert today on how we can help your business
Get Started
Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .
Clarity Tax + Accounting Hello! How can we help?
Welcome to ClarityBot--your smart assistant for clarifying payroll, bookkeeping and tax!
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully